9/27/2019

iPhone 11 Environmental Reports

iPhone 11 Environmental Reports

The iPhone 11 has been released, and it received many plaudits and a lot of positive feedback since Friday the 20th of September. Following the release of the devices, Apple also published the environmental reports for the new devices, which we will be analysing. Are Apple releases getting better or worse for the environment?

Every year we do a deep dive into the yearly environmental reports that Apple release, but alongside the general environmental report, they also release product scorecards for each of their new products detailing innovations in their supply chain and total emissions from production through to use and end-of life.

All devices have received a green-over, with Apple developing the methods and materials to build the new and more environmentally sustainable devices. We have detailed the iPhone's newest green credentials here and in this post we will be looking at the facts and figures provided by the environmental reports to see whether these improvements are making a difference to the overall CO2-e generated by each device.

The iPhone 11

The cheapest of the three models has more in common with the well-received and officially best selling iPhone XR, which has shifted the focus away from a budget moniker and has instead refocused on the premium aspect with the Pro models. The iPhone 11 should be in line with the lower emission models of the iPhone and we will be disclosing where each of these devices rank towards the end of this post.

Graph showing iPhone 11 CO2 Emissions per capacity

In the iPhone 11 environmental report, Apple compare the iPhone 11 to the iPhone XR, in terms of its emissions. We concluded last year that the iPhone XR was a step in the right direction for making phones more sustainable, however this year has moved once again in the opposite direction of emissions per product. Even though they are making supply chain improvements, these minor increases have been greatly exacerbated over the hundreds of millions of iPhones 11 they will inevitably sell.

iPhone XRiPhone 11Percentage change
64GB68kg CO2-e72kg CO2-e↑ 5.88%
128GB73kg CO2-e77kg CO2-e↑ 5.48%
256GB82kg CO2-e89kg CO2-e↑ 8.54%

The iPhone 11 Pro

We held out hope that the new Pro models were going to buck the trend of ever-increasing emissions per product. However, the iPhone 11 Pro comes with marginally higher emissions per product than the XS range. The XS range was already some of the highest emission iPhones ever, so to see an increase on last year's numbers is disappointing.

Graph showing iPhone 11 Pro CO2 Emissions per capacity

The largest jump actually comes from the medium tier 256GB capacity, jumping up by 4.35% from last year's equivalent model.

iPhone XSiPhone 11 ProPercentage change
64GB78kg CO2-e80kg CO2-e↑ 2.56%
256GB92kg CO2-e96kg CO2-e↑ 4.35%
512GB107kg CO2-e110kg CO2-e↑ 2.80%

The iPhone 11 Pro Max

The iPhone 11 Pro Max has the smallest increase on last year's iPhone XS Max, but the larger capacity model still comes in as the highest emission iPhone to date. Despite there being a larger focus on recycled material making up the components of the iPhone 11 range, the iPhone 11 Pro Max still tops the charts.

Graph showing iPhone 11 Pro Max CO2 Emissions per capacity

All configurations of the device are continuing to grow in emissions per device, however these are the smallest overall increases of all the iPhone 11 range.

iPhone XS MaxiPhone 11 Pro MaxPercentage change
64GB85kg CO2-e86kg CO2-e↑ 1.18%
256GB100kg CO2-e102kg CO2-e↑ 2%
512GB115kg CO2-e117kg CO2-e↑ 1.74%

All Devices Ranked

It is worth mentioning that older devices didn't have specific data based on capacity? We have now come to realise, capacity makes a big difference to the emissions from production.

DeviceTotal KG CO2eRank
iPhone 11 Pro Max 512GB1171
iPhone 6 Plus*1102=
iPhone 11 Pro 512GB1102=
iPhone XS Max 512GB1064
iPhone 11 Pro Max 256GB1025
iPhone XS 512GB996
iPhone 11 Pro 256GB967
iPhone 6*958
iPhone X 256GB939
iPhone XS Max 256GB9110
iPhone 11 256GB8911
iPhone 11 Pro Max 64GB8612
iPhone XS 256GB8513
iPhone 8 Plus 256GB8214
iPhone 11 Pro 64GB8015
iPhone X 64GB7916
iPhone XS Max 64GB7717
iPhone XR 256GB7618
iPhone 7 Plus 128GB7419
iPhone 11 128GB7320
iPhone 8 256GB7121
iPhone 5S*7022
iPhone XS 64GB7023=
iPhone 6S Plus 128GB7023=
iPhone 8 Plus 64GB6825=
iPhone 11 64GB6825=
iPhone 7 Plus 32GB6727=
iPhone XR 128GB6727=
iPhone 6S Plus 32GB6329=
iPhone 7 128GB6329=
iPhone XR 64GB6231
iPhone 6S 128GB6132
iPhone 8 64GB5733
iPhone 7 32GB5634
iPhone 4S*5535
iPhone 6S 32GB5436
iPhone SE 128GB5337
iPhone SE 32GB4538

*Emissions not detailed for different capacities

Conclusions

We are not going to say- 'don't buy the latest iPhone', as it's a great piece of kit and one of the best that they've released in years. Apple have done a lot of good for the industry and they are really focusing on their green credentials by using recycled materials and ensuring that all their offices and retail stores are running as waste-free and carbon-neutral as possible. However, if you want to make your next device as green as possible, there are some obvious choices that you can make.

By being more frugal with your storage space, you can save up to 31kg of CO2-e emissions, which is more emissions than the phone will use for the rest of its life, even at the highest speculation of usage and charging multiple times a day.

The lower capacity iPhone 11 has the lowest emissions of the lot, and it has the same CO2-e emissions as the iPhone 8 Plus and placed joint 25th.

All devices have seen a relative increase in greenhouse gas emissions compared to last year. While the Pro and the Pro Max have only increased by a small percentage, it is still an increase and is not going in the right direction. In fact, all device emissions have been increasing since the iPhone SE, with only the XR bucking the curve.

It could be the case that as the devices are using more recycled materials, recovery of these could be more energy-intensive, however there is very little information available which tells us why these devices have a higher emissions per product than in previous years. Apple claim that they are "about the same as {the previous model of similar screen size}", with no further explanation provided.

Andrew

Andrew

See more posts by Andrew

E-Waste Is Destroying Our Planet: Here Is What You Can Do to Break the Cycle

E-Waste Is Destroying Our Planet: Here Is What You Can Do to Break the Cycle

The connection between the planet and tech production might not be immediately obvious, but using and choosing smartphones more sustainably is in fact a way to stop e-waste. This International E-waste Day we highlight the importance of tackling e-waste and how this can be done on an individual level by sharing a few mindful practices to help you to close the loop.

There's One Issue With 5G We Can't Ignore

There's One Issue With 5G We Can't Ignore

5G hype is everywhere, but it isn't just going to have a colossal impact on mobile connectivity speed and wireless networks. It will also dramatically boost the rates of mobile phone waste if smartphone owners continue to be apathetic about smartphones' collective impact on the environment.

Co-Founder of Android Showcased a Weird, But Interesting Phone

Co-Founder of Android Showcased a Weird, But Interesting Phone

After years of silence, it looks as though Essential are ready for a new chapter and it is going to be an attempt to shake up the industry once again. Recently, Andy Rubin took to Twitter to share a Project Gem phone that looks like nothing we've seen before. The form factor reminds us of remote control which we all have at home, but for it to have the capabilities of a phone is something new.