Compare and Recycle

Who's on Santas Naughty List in 2018?

Santa’s naughty list of 2018 phones is out - we rate manufacturers to see who’s been good or bad this year in mobile tech.

andrew marchant author profile photo

Written by Andrew Marchant, Marketing Manager | Privacy, Money-Saving and Parenting Advice

Last updated on 17 December 2025

As Christmas day is finally drawing near, we look at the top manufacturers to see if any of them will make Santa's Nice list this year or will they be waking up on their hoards of cash with coal under the tree?

Google

The latest Pixel devices ended up bringing a huge list of issues with them. Even with excellent camera software performance, the gigantic notch and wide bezels feels like a lazy design flaw.

  • No 4K Video Recording at 60FPS,
  • Devices are prone to scratches,
  • A notch and still quite a chin,
  • Google thinks you can never have too many notches and Pixel users were attacked by random extra notches as a part of software issue.

Apple

Let's not talk about the exorbitantly high price of the Xs and to be honest, the XR... These were ultra expensive devices (even the budget range) with only a few upgrades and on top of that the device wouldn't charge with the display off! Additionally over beautified pictures caused by the selfie camera aggressively smoothing the skin of its subjects.

The iPhone XR faced same camera issues as well and Apple has confirmed that a fix is coming. We are still awaiting for Apple’s charging dock. What about the considerably buggy iOS 12 release? And how did iOS 12 affect older models? Oh yea, it slowed them down intentionally.

Did we also mention the environmental cost of each iPhone slowly creeping back up? Bad Apple, Bad!

Samsung

Or should we list the S-Pen specifically? Many users reported fragility of the new S-Pen. The pen has been breaking for a lot of Note 9 owners and the phone itself had a number of Bluetooth issues.  The company is staying away from notches and recent Galaxy A8s with Infinity-O display launch booked a place on the Nice list for Samsung next year.

OnePlus

Specced out devices with affordable prices are welcome by OnePlus fans but security and connectivity issues shouldn't come in a bundle. Some users reported that the auto brightness was not working as expected but the good news is that all problems with the recently launched 6T were officially confirmed to be fixed in upcoming updates‌‌. So they've not been too naughty, but Santa is keeping a keen eye on them.

Huawei

Users reporting random reboots on the P20 Pro and the 4,000 mAh should easily last an entire day, however users turned to forums to complain about a disappointing battery performance. Slow charging of the P20 Pro doesn't make it better and the (unsubstantiated) claim that the UK's internet spy agency isn’t totally confident in Huawei’s devices’ security makes this year a tough one for Huawei.

LG

A lot of complaints about the battery life on the G7 and this really should have been foreseen with the big 6.1-inch screen with a small 3,000 mAh battery. There were fingerprint scanner related problems reported. Users shared that the G7 can’t occasionally recognise a finger and initiates false fingerprint scanning causing the battery drain.

The V4o ThinQ wasn't without it's share of criticisms through 2018. The camera is the main selling point of this device. Actually 5 cameras. And there’s a lot of going on there when trying to snap a quick picture. The process can be pretty overwhelming and if you are offered to choose 5 good cameras or a Pixel 3 with 1 exceptional, we’ll go with one. Beyond the attention-grabbing quintuple camera set-up, V40 is actually pretty boring device and LG missed the opportunity this year to launch a flagship with remarkable features. We don't think this makes the naughty list, just highlights how excess can sully the nature.

It's not like mobile phone manufacturers totally screwed up this year. Remember the Note 7 disaster in 2016? Fortunately, this year promises to finish on a cheerful note, but somehow every single device launched this year carried a few issues along and degrading phones' performance is something Santa won't forget easily.

upright standing iphone in grey colour next to a smartspeaker

Why the iPhone No Longer Surprises Us

The iPhone used to define innovation. Now every new model feels the same. Is Apple’s story running out of pages?

sneha kashyap author profile photo
6 Min Read
phone depreciation report by compare and recycle

Annual Phone Depreciation Report

See which Apple, Samsung and Google phones hold their value best over the first and second year on the market.

antonia hristov author profile photo
14 Min Read
google pixel phones on a green background with downwards arrows

Google Pixel Depreciation Report

With Pixels becoming a decent contender for your upgrade choice, we’ve crunched the numbers to reveal depreciation patterns of Google Pixel phones.

antonia hristov author profile photo
7 Min Read